JUDGE’S EVALUATION – MS-1 STUDENT RESEARCH PROPOSAL

JUDGE’S EVALUATION
MS-1 STUDENT RESEARCH PROPOSAL
SUMMER RESEARCH PROGRAM

 

Research Trainee #:                                                                     Reviewer’s Name:                                                                    

 On a scale of  5 (Outstanding) to 1 (Poor) rate the proposal on the following  criteria:

 

Proposal	Does the proposal provide in the student’s own words a concise summary and description of the work to be done (i.e., the student did not simply cut and paste sections of the original grant)?
Hypothesis	Is the hypothesis, problem or question well focused, clearly stated and conveyed convincingly?
Background	Does the proposal provide sufficient background information to understand the problem under study?
Significance	Is the problem under study important to the health or welfare of patients and/or to society at large?
Experimental Design	Are the methods and procedures appropriate, and their description adequate?
Personal Statement	Has student shown strong desire to do research?

                                                                                                                                                                                             TOTAL SCORE:                                                                                                                                                                                                                               (out of 30)

COMMENTS FOR COMMITTEE REQUIRED**:                                                                                      

**Reviewer comments required if you cannot attend the meeting to discuss your evaluation.